What will the SI honour mean for Dan Shulman?
December 13, 2009 · 11 Comments
Dan Shulman is in that rare position of being a media star abroad, but his work on ESPN largely unknown at home.
He lives just north of Toronto where he says many of his friends and family don’t really know what he does.
In the United States, however, he is among the leading play by play voices in sports television. Last Friday, his profile skyrocketed when Sports Illustrated selected him the top national announcer for the first decade of this century, beating out broadcast icons such as Al Michaels, Joe Buck and Jim Nantz.
Shulman, who works for ESPN, said he was shocked by the selection.
“I was called by my agent 10 minutes before it was posted online,” he said. “I had absolutely no idea.”
ESPN isn’t available in Canada. And since it’s been eight years since Shulman worked for TSN and even longer on Toronto radio, his profile in this country has diminished.
“Most of my friends and family have no idea what I do anymore,” he said. “Most of them either don’t have the Rogers NBA digital sports package, or can’t quite figure out how to find the games, or something like that.
“I know my dad’s got it down pat. He watches every game, so he’s figured out how. I wish more of the stuff I did down there was visible here, because this is home.”
Shulman, teamed with the singular Dick Vitale, is ESPN’s lead college basketball voice and also calls NBA and baseball games for the network. He’s No.3 on the ESPN/ABC lineup of NBA announcers behind Mike Breen and Mike Tirico. He’s occasionally heard on the ABC doubleheader. On Jan. 31, he will fill in for Tirico.
Like all lists, the SI broadcasting selections will stimulate debate. Picking Mary Carillo of tennis as the top game analyst was must plain wrong. And CBS’s Nantz gets snubbed somewhat. The Shulman choice was outside the box, because he works for a cable channel rather than a broadcast network. But as Ralph Mellanby, the veteran sports producer, said this weekend, he is the complete package. He has probably the best voice in U.S. sports television. He’s smart, likeable on and off the air, and always impeccably prepared.
SI.com’s Richard Deitsch, who compiled the list, wrote, “While he might not have the same cachet as Al Michaels, Jim Nantz or Joe Buck, Shulman is the best national play-by-play announcer today. He is exceptional at multiple sports (NBA and MLB), and he and his baseball partner, Dave Campbell, form as splendid a duo as there is on radio. As ESPN’s lead announcer, Shulman has made Dick Vitale palatable (at times) and deserves an award for that alone. The guy is a pro’s pro.”
Just what this selection does for Shulman’s career remains to be seen. He figures not much, and he says he isn’t looking for anything.
“It’s very flattering,” he said. “I’m just honoured to be mentioned among the other guys who are on the list. I don’t think it really changes anything about me. I just keep doing the same thing I’m doing. Go to work, do the game and come home. It’s not in my nature to get too caught up in something like that. I’m incredibly flattered and honoured, but I don’t think it will have a tangible impact on my career that I can foresee anyway.”
Shulman’s first job in broadcasting was in Barrie, Ont., with CKBB radio. He worked at Toronto’s Fan all-sports station in the early 1990s and then joined TSN. Choosing to continue living in Toronto, he commutes to his ESPN assignments, spending between 160 and 180 nights a year in hotel rooms.
Shulman, 42, is in the third year of a five year deal with ESPN. It’s hard to believe there will not be competition for his services when his contract comes up for renewal. Still, he says he’s happy in his present position.
“I’m beyond thrilled to be doing what I’m doing right now. I don’t look ahead too much. I try to just enjoy it.”
SI’s choice as best broadcaster of the decade was Bob Costas, who works for HBO and MLB Network, but is mainly known as an NBC host and the network’s Olympic prime time anchor. Deitsch wrote, “There is no harder job in sports broadcasting than hosting an Olympic Games, a gig that requires equal parts geopolitical expert, historian, traffic cop and journalist.”
In ranking Carillo the top game analyst in the business Deitsch describes her as “honest, thoughtful and always prepared . . . Carillo has excelled in a sport that far too often soft-pedals commentary because of the many conflicts of interests and relationships. She provides a reporter’s eye in the booth.”
It’s another outside the box choice, but hardly inspired. Carillo’s work is superficial. She can be snarky, but there isn’t even much of that anymore. And she rarely conveys a smart, insightful analysis. The best analysts in tennis are the McEnroes, John and Patrick.
Nantz is largely ignored by the list. He’s a bit of a softy, but his work in golf is fine, and he’s a serviceable announcer and host. The list gives him an honourable mention in college basketball play by play and as a studio host.



“What will the SI honour mean for Dan Shulman?” – How about a Multi Million Dollar deal on his next contract. Good for him!
Great article William, I enjoy Shulman’s work. I hadn’t heard him do anything for ESPN for years, then last year I starting subscribing to Raptors TV and watching ESPN’s NBA Friday games if I’m home on Friday, since then I’ve had the chance to hear him a lot more. I really hope that this award will give ESPN some incentive to promote him to the Sunday Night Baseball TV position soon, he is so much better than Miller.
I am surprised that Michaels didn’t get the award. To me he is the best play by play in sports right now, but I guess he has only did MNF and SNF this decade mostly, while Shulman has did college hoops, NBA and baseball.
Man. hard to believe he’s gone on to so much success. I remember when he was the kind-of-nerdy third wheel with McCown and BarbDiGiulio. What did they call themselves… Lady and the Tramps? Something like that.
I can even remember his promo about winding up in radio because when he went to apply at the school paper the line was out the door. I guess that worked out OK for him.
Sir:
I have to agree with Clarkenstein; any true sports fan is ABSOLUTELY aware of Dan’s work and the breadth of his success. How could his profile have diminished? He is more regularly on a national (and international) stage than he ever was as FAN/TSN Can-con guy. Perhaps what you wished to infer was that most sports followers aren’t intimately aware of his nationality? But please don’t try to suggest to the regular readers of your sports media commentary that the 49th parallel is suddenly a limitation to accessing sports programming from the ‘ole US of A.
Ironic that this award comes just days after Buck M. was hired by Sportsnet to do the BJays games- I would contend that Buck’s evolution as a broacaster was the result of working alongside a natural PBP man like Shulman…if there is anyone current who does a better job of playing to his partners’ strengths I’ve yet to hear him.
Among my favourite times of any summertime week are Sunday night drives home from the cottage listening to Dan and Soupy, and Wed nights on Prime Time when Bob McCown’s ego allows someone more captivating than himself onto the show.
Congrats Dan, and we’ll keep listening- because we do indeed know where to go to hear you.
A tremendous honour indeed for Dan Shulman. All of us who listened to Shulman from his days at TheFan 590 and TSN knew he had world class talent. Sports Illustrated’s award means his star will just keep on rising. Congrats, Danny Boy.
“Largely unknown at home”??? You’re kidding right? Of course he’s well known at home… as well as any other baseball announcer is known in Canada or the U.S. Baseball announcers aren’t what they once were. It used to be a job for life but now that has changed. Any baseball fan in Canada knows who Dan is… just not in the GTA perhaps.
Let me try to explain it to you and Jay Lack. His work on ESPN is largely unknown in Canada. And, yes, eight years after he called his last game for TSN, his profile has diminished.
Shulman could teach every broadcaster in Canada what it means to be a “pro” There is no one in this country who comes close to his grace, class and knowledge. An honour well deserved!!!
Wow. Before Shulman did Jay games (where he is sorely missed), I remember listening to him host Prime Time Sports with Jim Hunt. Very different vibe from McCown, but he was great. I remember he used to host ‘Hoops’ on The Fan too – it was on Sunday mornings I think. Nice to see him be so successful. Actually, speaking of successful Fan alums, I think Shulman might have been there around the same time that George Strombolopolous was doing overnights and weekends on The Fan, funnily enough.